Scientific method in Ptolemy's 'Harmonics'

TitleScientific method in Ptolemy's 'Harmonics'
Publication TypeBook
Year of Publication2000
AuthorsBarker, A
Ancient AuthorsClaudius Ptolemaeus Math. (TLG 0363)
Number of Pagesviii + 281 pp. ill.
PublisherCambridge University Press
ISBN9780521553728 (hb); 9780521028646 (pb); 9780511038082 (ebook)

The science called 'harmonics' was one of the major intellectual enterprises of Greek antiquity. Ptolemy's treatise seeks to invest it with new scientific rigour; its consistently sophisticated procedural self-awareness marks it as a key text in the history of science. This book is a sustained methodological exploration of Ptolemy's project. After an analysis of his explicit pronouncements on the science's aims and the methods appropriate to it, it examines Ptolemy's conduct of his investigation in detail, concluding that despite occasional uncertainties, the declared procedure is followed with remarkable fidelity. Ptolemy pursues tenaciously his novel objective of integrating closely the project's theoretical and empirical phases and shows astonishing mastery of the concept, the design and the conduct of controlled experimental tests. By opening up this neglected text to historians of science, the book aims to provide a point of departure for wider studies of Greek scientific method. []


G&R 2001 Ser. 2 48 (2): 227-228 William Harry Manning; LEC 2001 69 (3): 332-333 Michel Federspiel; MH 2001 58 (4): 235 Werner Schubert; BJHS 2002 35 (3): 349-350 Karin Tybjerg; AC 2003 72: 489-490 François Duysinx; CW 2002-2003 96 (3): 329-330 Jon Solomon; JHPh 2003 41 (1): 123-124 Heike Sefrin-Weis; Phronesis 2003 48 (1): 85 Keimpe A. Algra; CB 2004 80 (1): 94-96 Tracey E. Rihll.; Il saggiatore musicale 2001 8 (2): 317-325 M. Raffa

Site information

© 2007-2012 MOISA: International Society for the Study of Greek and Roman Music and Its Cultural Heritage

Site designed by Geoff Piersol and maintained by Stefan Hagel
All rights reserved.